The Secularization of Spirituality

Sociologists Christian Smith and Melinda Lundquist Denton coined a phrase in 2005 (that has since become mainstream religious vocabulary) to describe the de facto spirituality of teenagers growing up in Christian Churches.  They summarized the main tenets of Moral Therapeutic Deism in five points: 

  • A God exists who created and orders the world and watches over human life on earth.

  • God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other, as taught in the Bible and by most world religions.

  • The central goal of life is to be happy and to feel good about oneself.

  • God does not need to be particularly involved in one’s life except when God is needed to resolve a problem.

  • Good people go to heaven when they die.

 

It only takes a moment’s thought to see how divergent this is from actual Christianity. As a spiritual structure it is devoid of any meaningful contact with the teaching of Scripture, the tradition of the Church, or the reality of human experience. It is rooted in a series of assumptions that are utterly unfounded in and alien to the Christian faith. And if you think that is too strident, ask yourself where Jesus features in the summary points above? If there was ever an argument fort he recovery of intentional and rigorous disciple-making, the fact that this vacuous pseudo-faith is the functional spirituality of a generation growing up in our Churches is it…

Let’s take each aspect of the moniker in turn:

‘Moral’ comes from the concern to be a generally good person, although it is far from clear that there is any specifically Christian framework shaping the vision of what being a ‘good’ person entails.  Indeed, the evidence points to an understanding of ‘good’ that is specifically sub-, if not anti-Christian.  This links with the second point listed by Smith & Denton above: God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other, as taught in the Bible and by most world religions. Laying aside the ignorance this displays of both the Bible and of ‘most world religions’, this impoverished ideal falls dangerously short of Christ’s vision for holiness. Especially when laid aside the stated goal of life, this ‘morality’ turns in on itself, and becomes the very antithesis of even the most basic commands to love the Lord our God and our neighbour. Being ‘nice’ becomes a self-serving mechanism that allows me ‘to feel good about myself’ (the central goal of my life, as opposed to e.g. ‘Glorify God and enjoy Him forever’, WSC Q&A 1.); and ensuring my entrance to heaven (based on my moral performance, note again the total lack of any doctrine of the cross, imputed righteousness, grace, etc.).

Many ‘Christians’ in the UK today have only the slightest idea of the doctrine of sin, and almost certainly underplay any notion they do have to such an extent that it no longer threatens their own sense of being an inherently ‘good’ person, as indeed they perceive most people to be, even before they become Christians.  The idea of sin as original, or inherited, as all-encompassing, and as corrupting everything we do, is simply something that many growing up in Christian Churches have no category for.  Although they claim to be Christian, they function as utilitarian.  Utilitarianism is a self-consciously secular (i.e. without reference to Christ) way of doing ethics (conceived of and developed by Bentham & Mill), in which an action is judged to be good or right if it tends to promote happiness or pleasure, and to be wrong or evil if it tends to produce unhappiness or pain - usually for everyone else affected by it, though the effect on the actor is also part of the ‘equation’.  Actions therefore should be evaluated as good or bad, right or wrong on the basis of their consequences.  Crudely, something judged to benefit other people is good, whereas something that harms them is wrong.  This is so embedded in our cultural ethic that it barely needs illustration.  It is perhaps most commonly stated in its passive sense that ‘How can it be wrong if it doesn’t hurt anyone…’. 

Within the Church its uncritical appropriation is betrayed by the comment: I know people who aren’t Christians who are better people than some of the Christians I know; or by the category of ‘good people’ who aren’t Christians.  How we define morality is crucial for a clear vision of Christian experience, worship and discipleship.  We need to define our ethics in specifically and exclusively Christian terms, and to teach our people to do so: in terms of faith in Christ (without which it is impossible to please Him) and love for Him that articulates itself in obedience to His commands.  What makes something ‘good’ is a question we must answer clearly and in Biblical terms.

‘Deism’ is the idea that God made the world and then stepped away from it, leaving it to run without further interference according to ‘natural laws’ that are self-sustaining and intrinsic to the world.  Generally for those functioning within a MTD paradigm, God is not intimately involved (see point 4 above).  My own experience is that people are not particularly consistent in this tenet of their world-view.  There is often anger and frustration with God for not being there to stop bad things happening, with people sometimes being so overwhelmed by the reality of suffering and evil in the world that they ‘de-construct’ their faith.  Although it serves to ‘protect’ their idea of God from the pain and struggle of living in a cursed and fallen world (we can’t blame God for bad things people do), and to equally ‘protect’ their cherished vision for their freedom to act as they want, and be who they want (what historically has been thought of as ‘free will’), there lingers the expectation that God ought to act in isolated and often direct and dramatic ways in terms of people’s experience (usually in sung worship), to protect people (sometimes from the consequences of their own sin), and to alleviate suffering (because that is what any loving P/person would do). 

Deism also critically undermines the place of several Christian doctrines, such as Providence, and with it, God’s involvement in and ordaining of the circumstances of our lives to discipline and redeem, re-forging in us the Imago Dei.  For many in today’s Church, this may prove the main attraction of functional deism.  As we’ve just noted, the Deism of the modern Church is highly selective.  In real terms it may come down to the assumption that God is not so involved in my life as to tell me what to believe, who to be, and how to live, to impinge in any meaningful way on my freedom to express who I believe I am; but can be expected to be involved when things are inimical to my ‘happiness’.

‘Therapeutic’ speaks to a concern about feelings and particularly the sense of well-being.  Crudely this equates to our learning to love and accept ourselves as we are, and to expect validation from others (including God) when they love and accept us for who we are.  For many in today’s (Western) Church, the question of how or what I feel is far more powerful than the question of what is true (in fact the two are often conflated in people’s thinking), or even what should be believed or aspired to.  In an absolute text-book study of how Christianity has been distorted a secularist culture (smuggled in due to lack of intentional discipleship), values and beliefs are deemed largely relative (it works for you, so I couldn’t possibly disagree), and are divorced from questions of faith and relationship with God, or the presence and empowering of the Holy Spirit.  It provides a spiritual milieu in which we become the arbiters of our own truth, the source of our own fulfilment, and the forgers of our own meaning.  Being a Christian is re-cast to become an expectation of my being resourced to live my life based on what is important to me; and there is no sense of accountability except when beliefs or behaviour are deemed to adversely affect others or wider society.  Spirituality, such as it is, is individualized and privatized.[1]  Evangelism is chronically undermined, as it entails an implicit criticism of others’ beliefs or behaviour.  Worship becomes an act of self-validation from which I want to emerge ‘feeling better about myself’, affirmed in my renewed confidence that I am acceptable to and accepted by God.  Faith serves to bolster my self-esteem, and God serves as the foundation of my sense of being unconditionally loved and therefore validated.  

 

Of course, this isn’t a peculiarly Christian set of observations and commentary.  Douglas Murray, after exposing how ‘all of our grand narratives have collapsed’, makes the salient point that secularism cannot be the first culture ‘in recorded history to have absolutely no explanation for what we are doing here, and no story to give life purpose’.  His conclusion is simply that we aren’t.  Secularism, in spite of the naïve claims made for it’s sufficiency, has always been inherently unstable.  Robbing its adherents (and those unfortunate enough to have been shaped by their vision) of any transcendence, human spirituality has inevitably turned in on itself.  We are in fact facing a new religious context, ‘one built on commitment to individual autonomy and celebration of personal authenticity at any cost’.[2]  Secularism rejected the idea of anything transcendent, and told us that there were no questions of ultimate meaning to answer. But there are. And Secularism’s failure to even recognize them is the failure of Secularism. Our undeniable instinct to answer them has been left to flounder in world we are no longer able to navigate. We might expect this from the world, but to find it has been normalized within the Church, and that it has become indistinguishable for many from genuine Christianity is terrifying. To be ignorant is dangerous. To be ignorant of our ignorance is disastrous. And as all fallen spiritualties must, this one too stands in hostility to the Gospel of Christ.  There is no such thing as a dogmatic vacuum.  If we remove a genuinely Biblical vision of God revealed in Christ through the Gospel, we inevitably build an idol to take its place.

Bruce concurs, ‘What remains of British Christianity has seen a significant shift in a secular direction; increasingly concerned not with pleasing God, but with therapeutic improvement in the lives of believers, who have become more assertive in deciding what they will believe and how much they will commit’.[3]  In such a spiritual context it will take some effort to build even a category for discipleship.

What we have seen in the Church has been a shift in focus to personal experience and fulfilment (in largely materialist terms) at the expense of Biblically central, and traditionally non-negotiable elements of the Christian faith.  This last point should not be missed.  Given the extent to which it distorts Creedal Christianity it is odd that so few seem able to distinguish the two.  The shift may have been noticed, but rather than being decried it has been celebrated.  And the pragmatically driven ecclesiology that has become de rigueur in recent decades has allowed it to set up a mutually reinforcing ‘loop’ in Christian gatherings and worship services / events.  As such Moral Therapeutic Deism is legitimized by the songs we sing, the sermons we hear, and the prayers we offer, and are offered by Christian retailers and resourcers.

 

Moral Therapeutic Deism, and Creedal Christianity are not only altogether removed from each other but are in fact mutually exclusive.  Any superficial similarities stop at the use of a common vocabulary: God, love, acceptance.  And in terms of discipleship, not even the vocabulary is common.  The language of holiness, righteousness, sacrifice, self-denial, of ‘taking up our cross’ has no place in MTD.  The disciplines of repentance, and of precisely recognising that we are not ‘authentically’ human until we are conformed to the image of Christ (the authentic human) are noticeable only by their absence in the spiritual experience of many contemporary Christians.  Blessed are the poor in spirit… those who mourn… the meek… those who hunger and thirst after righteousness… those who are persecuted because of righteousness…  the Beatitudes do not sit well with a secularized spirituality.  Christ, who as we have just noticed is the authentic human, categorically rejected precisely this self-fulfillment vision for humanity, recognizing it for the Satanically inspired counterfeit that it was (Matt.4:1-11).  This was the path to death and destruction.  He chose another way.  He laid aside His status and His rights, and found His joy and life in taking on the role of a servant.  Thus, He was exalted by His Father.  Christian spirituality precisely sacrifices self for the sake of the Gospel, and for the loving of others, trusting God for the future.  He exposes the quest for ‘authenticity’ as the self-aggrandizing project that it is.

It turns out that we are not the ones who give ourselves meaning.  That prerogative belongs exclusively to God.  This is the model of humanity that Jesus left for us.

Churches are complicit in cultivating this new spirituality insofar as they re-compose corporate worship to a secularized tune.  Fewer Churches include an act of confession as ‘sin’ becomes an increasingly obsolete category.  Morality, if preached at all, is rooted in self-fulfillment.  Scripture is redacted and brought to the service of affirmation and support for our self-actualization.   Our attempts to re-fashion Christian worship to fit a secularized spirituality (often in the name of making Christianity ‘accessible’) have in fact meant the loss of the Gospel as the deciding feature in shaping our services.[4]  We risk becoming co-dependent with congregations who have lost any sense of what it means to hold a Gospel-centered faith.  We avoid passages of Scripture that might cause offense; eliminate songs and hymns that speak to less-than-affirming aspects of Christian belief and experience; and allow a sub-/non- Christian belief system to dictate the nature of a service and the criteria for its success.  The prophetic elements of the faith are lost to this generation, and any minister who seeks to revive it will face the discontent, if not the anger of their shrinking congregations. 

In part this is because many Churches have succumbed to the bizarre idea that we should structure our worship and mission around the (felt) ‘needs’ of people and communities.  Apart from reinforcing an ego-centric and fundamentally consumerist spirituality, it manages to miss the point that people don’t actually know what they need.   ‘Unconverted people do not know their need in any comprehensive way’ (Webber).  And if in some deeply Augustinian sense they know their hearts are restless, that will be aligned to a quest for stillness and meaning that is absent of Christ.  No community or individual survey, discussion or listening exercise, or research will end with the declaration that ‘we need Jesus’.  They need to learn that they need Him, and why, and they need to be taught how to articulate that need.  They need to ‘learn the language of faith’.  That will take time and we must be sensitive to the fact that experience can often overtake understanding… or the ability to articulate that experience well. 

But instead, we de-Christianize the Gospel. 

Such spirituality (and the corporate community and worship to which it gives rise) is devastatingly sub-Christian (if Christian at all).  It is hopelessly anthropocentric, consumeristic, and hedonistic.  There is no category for the self-suspicion that characterized previous generations of Christians.   Our ignorance of the Gospel and our conviction of our own self-worth and significance combine to produce a misplaced security and confidence in our relationship with God.  We suspect that what we intuitively do and naturally believe is ‘right’, and acceptable to the Lord.  When ‘sincerity’ is cast as the defining feature of legitimate worship, and ‘authenticity’ is deemed the sole criteria of truth, we struggle to grasp that the Lord might not be thrilled with whatever we consider appropriate to offer.  We remain to be convinced that we need to be taught anything.  We are convinced we see clearly when in fact we are blinded by our spiritual conceit.  In the absence of rigorous Christian discipleship formation, many ‘Christians’ are in fact ‘Moral Therapeutic Deists’ who neither understand nor practice Christian belief, worship or discipleship.  Their spirituality is uncritically shaped by their cultural context.  Hence there is no appetite for, or even the awareness of the need for Christian growth.  Indeed, such are likely to resist it, seeing it as inimical to their self-perceived needs, and expectations of the Church.  If we have accepted the lies of our culture – that personal fulfilment and happiness is our highest good - then we will surrender at the first sign of spiritual trouble of hardship (Jn.16:33).

A generation ago, Jurgen Moltmann sought to sound the alarm: ‘Behind the social and political crisis of the Church in the modern society there stands the Christological Crisis.  From whom does the Church really take its bearings?  Who is Jesus Christ, really, for us today?  In this identity crisis of Christianity, the question of God lies hidden.  Which God governs Christian existence – the One who was crucified, or the idols of religion, class, race and society?  Without a new clarity in the Christian faith itself, there will be no credibility in the Christian life’.

His cry went unheeded.


[1] Wiley, Cosmos, The idea of individualism is born in the 18th / 19th centuries. ‘What these modern philosophers did was … tried conceptually to isolate individuals from the communities that they are born into.  At first this was done in order to understand why individuals should want to live in political communities.  But it soon developed into a way to liberate people from the constraints of social institutions in general, such as households for example’.

[2] Cited McAlpine, Being the Bad Guys, 28

[3] Bruce, British gods, 252, emphasis added

[4] Dreher comments that MTD is the natural religion of a culture that worships ‘self’ and material comfort.  The Church, he contends, cannot continue to exist if such thinking takes hold within it.  ‘We may deny that God is dead, but to adopt Moral Therapeutic Deism is to concede that He is in hospice care’ Benedictine Option, 44

Previous
Previous

historical background

Next
Next

Project Three